I've owned dogs for the past 12 years of my adult life, and one thing that's evolved over that time is my perspective on dog food. If there's one thing I'm adamant about, it's that a dog's diet should be complete and balanced to ensure they're getting all the nutrients they need. Whether someone chooses to feed kibble, fresh, or raw doesn't particularly matter to me, as long as their dog is getting proper nutrition.
Over the years, I've become increasingly interested in foods made with whole, recognizable ingredients. And thankfully, there are more options than ever for pet owners who want to incorporate whole foods into their pets' diets, regardless of how they choose to feed. Along with researching the ingredients and nutritional information, I've also been trying many of these foods with my own pets so I can share my firsthand experiences. While my own experience has primarily been with dogs, I've also included some whole-food-based options for cats in this article.
Disclosure: Some of the pet foods featured in this article were provided complimentary by their respective brands, while others were purchased with my own money. All opinions are my own, and receiving complimentary products does not guarantee a positive review. This article may also contain affiliate links, meaning I may earn a small commission if you purchase through them, at no additional cost to you.
Want to skip straight to the food reviews?
Jump to Section
What Is Whole-Food-Based Pet Food?
For the purpose of this article, when I say “whole-food-based,” I'm referring to foods that rely primarily on nutrient-rich, whole-food ingredients to meet nutritional requirements rather than extensive synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes. Some of the brands featured here rely entirely on whole-food ingredients for nutritional balancing, while others add just a few specific nutrients, such as zinc, manganese, or taurine.
You'll also notice that quite a few of these foods contain mixed tocopherols, which are forms of vitamin E commonly derived from plant oils. They're typically added as natural antioxidants to help preserve freshness and prevent fats from going rancid. I don't consider a few targeted additions like these a reason to exclude an otherwise whole-food-based food, especially when the brand isn't relying on a long list of added vitamins and minerals to make its recipes complete and balanced.
But finding foods that meet these criteria isn't nearly as easy as you might think.
Take a look at the ingredient list on the back of your dog's current food. Chances are, you'll find quite a few ingredients you don't recognize or aren't entirely sure why they're included. One thing worth knowing is that pet food ingredients are listed in order by weight, so the ingredients at the beginning of the list make up the largest portions of the recipe by weight before processing. But that doesn't necessarily tell you how much nutritional value each ingredient contributes.
For example, let's look at one of the most recognizable dog food brands, Purina Dog Chow. Its ingredient list includes whole grain corn, meat and bone meal (what meat, exactly??), corn protein meal, chicken by-product meal, a long list of added vitamins and minerals, and even artificial food coloring.
Now, that doesn't automatically mean these ingredients are harmful or lack nutritional value. But it's certainly a different approach from the whole-food-based diets I'm talking about. And to be fair, this is one of Purina's more budget-friendly formulas. The reality, though, is that many commercial dog foods rely on added vitamins and minerals to meet nutritional requirements, even some of the more expensive brands.
What Are Synthetic Vitamins and Minerals?
Synthetic vitamins are manufactured nutrients rather than vitamins supplied directly by whole-food ingredients like meat, organs, fish, or vegetables. Minerals can't technically be synthesized in the same way, but manufacturers can add processed mineral compounds to provide essential nutrients. These are often combined into what's called a vitamin and mineral premix, which you'll find in many commercial pet foods.
So, why does this matter?
One thing to consider is how well these nutrients are absorbed and used by the body, also known as bioavailability. Some forms of supplemental vitamins and minerals are absorbed better than others, and the same is true for nutrients found naturally in food. It really depends on the specific nutrient and its source.
Another consideration is what happens during processing. Many conventional kibbles are manufactured using high temperatures and pressure, which can reduce the levels of certain naturally occurring vitamins. Manufacturers have to account for these losses during production, as well as any nutrients that may degrade during storage.
There have been cases where excessive amounts of vitamins were added to commercial dog foods and caused toxicity. For example, in 2019, Hill's recalled several canned dog foods after excessive levels of vitamin D were discovered due to an error involving a vitamin premix supplier. The FDA received reports of vitamin D toxicity in dogs that consumed affected foods. And this isn't meant to scare you! These situations are uncommon, and added vitamins and minerals are generally a safe, effective, and affordable way to make pet foods complete and balanced.
I just personally prefer a more natural, whole-food approach to nutrition, both for my dogs and myself. When possible, I'd rather see those nutrients coming from nutrient-rich food ingredients instead of relying heavily on a premix. One thing I appreciate about whole foods is that they provide more than just isolated vitamins and minerals. Take beef liver, for example. It's naturally rich in vitamin A, copper, B vitamins, protein, and other nutrients. Rather than adding each of those nutrients individually, I like the idea of incorporating ingredients that naturally provide several of them at once. That doesn't automatically make a food better, but it's something I've come to value when choosing what to feed my dogs.
How Can Pet Food Be Complete and Balanced Without a Synthetic Vitamin and Mineral Premix?
First, let's talk about what "complete and balanced" actually means. The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) establishes nutritional standards for dog and cat food, including the essential nutrients pets need and the amounts required for different life stages. A food labeled complete and balanced must meet those nutritional requirements or pass an appropriate feeding trial. This means it can be fed as a pet's primary diet without needing additional supplements to fill nutritional gaps.
This is one of the main reasons manufacturers add vitamin and mineral premixes to pet food. They're a relatively easy and affordable way to make sure the finished food contains all the required nutrients in the proper amounts. But those nutrients don't necessarily have to come from a premix! Ingredients like organ meats, fish, eggs, seeds, and shellfish naturally provide a wide variety of essential vitamins and minerals. By carefully combining these ingredients, manufacturers can formulate complete and balanced diets with little to no added supplementation. It's a more complicated approach because they have to account for the nutritional contributions and natural variations of each ingredient, but it can absolutely be done.
One thing to remember is that an ingredient list can tell you what's in a food, but it can't tell you whether the finished recipe provides all the nutrients your pet needs. That's why nutritional adequacy statements and proper formulation matter so much.
And that's what makes the brands featured below so interesting! I've focused specifically on complete and balanced pet foods that rely primarily on whole-food ingredients for nutrition, with minimal or no added vitamins and minerals. I'll also highlight anything particularly noteworthy about their ingredients and formulations, along with what makes each brand unique and my own experiences feeding it. Some of these companies offer supplemental products or DIY-style formulas as well, but those aren't the foods I'm recommending as complete diets.
Jump to a Brand
Looking for a specific type of pet food? I've organized the brands below by feeding style, from traditional kibble and air-dried foods to gently cooked and raw diets. All of the brands featured offer complete and balanced recipes, although nutritional adequacy and added supplements can vary between individual formulas.
Kibble, Baked & Air-Dried Foods:
Fresh & Gently Cooked Foods:
Raw & Freeze-Dried Foods:
Best Whole-Food-Based Kibble, Baked & Air-Dried Pet Foods
Finding shelf-stable dog foods without extensive synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes was surprisingly difficult, especially when it came to traditional kibble! That's partly because the high temperatures used during conventional kibble manufacturing can reduce certain naturally occurring nutrients, making it more challenging to formulate a complete diet without supplementation.
Thankfully, there are some interesting alternatives. Several of the brands below use baking, air-drying, or other processing methods that allow them to incorporate nutrient-rich whole foods while still offering the convenience of a shelf-stable diet.
Nature's Logic
Surprisingly, Nature's Logic is the only traditional kibble brand I've been able to find that doesn't use synthetic vitamins or minerals. Honestly, that's pretty much their whole thing—what they're known for!
We fed Nature's Logic for about eight years, and I'd say the quality of this food has always been great. Our dogs maintained healthy weights, had great coats, consistent stools, and plenty of energy. One thing worth mentioning is that their kibble pieces are quite small, even for their dog food. Personally, I never found that to be an issue with our large dogs, but it's something to keep in mind if you prefer a larger kibble size. We also recently started feeding Nature's Logic to Dorian, our Maine Coon kitten, and he seems to really enjoy it, especially their canned food!
One of my FAVORITE things about Nature's Logic was how similar the ingredients were across their different protein formulas. This made rotating proteins incredibly easy, and we regularly switched between recipes without any issues. That's a huge plus in my book, especially when feeding multiple dogs!
Another thing worth mentioning is their recall history—or lack thereof! Since the brand launched in 2006, Nature's Logic has had no documented product recalls as of October 2026. That's an impressive track record for a brand that's been around for roughly 20 years, and definitely something I appreciate. Their product lineup includes dog and cat kibble, canned foods, toppers, treats, and more, all centered around their philosophy of providing nutrition through whole-food ingredients rather than synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes.
So, how do they make a complete and balanced kibble without adding synthetic vitamins and minerals?
Nature's Logic uses a combination of nutrient-rich ingredients like liver, sardines, pumpkin seed flour, dried kelp, fruits, and vegetables to naturally provide essential vitamins and minerals. One of their more interesting ingredients is porcine plasma, which comes from the liquid portion of pig's blood. It naturally contains iron, calcium, phosphorus, magnesium, amino acids, and other nutrients. According to Nature's Logic, this is one of the ingredients that allows them to formulate their foods without relying on synthetic supplements.
Another interesting ingredient is millet, which you don't see nearly as often in dog food as corn, rice, or potatoes. Millet is an ancient grain that's naturally gluten-free and provides nutrients like B vitamins, minerals, protein, and fiber. Nature's Logic uses non-GMO proso millet as a starch source to help hold their kibble together. I think it's an interesting choice because it serves a purpose in the manufacturing process while also contributing nutritional value. And when properly processed, millet can be highly digestible for dogs.
Even though their kibble contains millet, the majority of its protein still comes from animal ingredients. According to Nature's Logic, at least 85% of the protein in their Original line and 90% in their Distinction line comes from meat sources. Keep in mind, that's the percentage of protein coming from meat, not the percentage of meat in the food itself.
Something else worth mentioning is their approach to nutritional adequacy. Nature's Logic has used AAFCO feeding trials to help substantiate their foods' nutritional completeness. Many of their recipes carry statements indicating they're comparable in nutritional adequacy to a product substantiated through AAFCO feeding trials.
What products do they offer?
Nature's Logic offers several dry food lines, including Original, Distinction, and Pure Naturals, along with canned dog and cat foods, treats, toppers, and supplements. They have a pretty impressive variety of protein options, including chicken, beef, lamb, pork, rabbit, sardine, turkey, venison, and more. Their grain-inclusive kibble uses millet, while their grain-free recipes use tapioca starch derived from cassava root instead of relying on ingredients like peas, potatoes, or other legumes.
After feeding Nature's Logic for so many years, it's a brand I feel very comfortable recommending to anyone interested in a whole-food-based kibble. Our experience with it was consistently positive, and I especially appreciate that they've made this style of nutrition available to people who prefer feeding kibble rather than fresh or raw food.
Where to Buy: Nature's Logic is available on Amazon, Chewy, and through participating local pet food retailers.
Disclosure: Nature's Logic provided complimentary products for this article.
Carna4
Carna4 is a family-owned Canadian pet food company that produces whole-food-based dry diets for dogs and cats without synthetic vitamin or mineral premixes. Unlike traditional extruded kibble, their food is briefly baked and then air-dried, creating a shelf-stable nugget that doesn't require refrigeration. One of the most interesting things about Carna4 is its use of organic sprouted seeds, which play an important role in how the company formulates its food.
The food itself surprised me a little. The nuggets are light-colored and incredibly lightweight, almost like little cookies! They have a firm texture, but don't feel quite like traditional kibble or freeze-dried food. The Chicken Recipe also packs 500 calories into a standard cup, so it's worth paying attention to portions. And I appreciate that the bag is resealable, especially with a food at this price point.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
Carna4 uses a combination of meat, organs, eggs, vegetables, fruits, and its signature blend of USDA-certified organic sprouted seeds to supply essential nutrients. Sprouting involves allowing seeds to begin germinating, which changes their nutritional composition and can improve the availability of certain nutrients. Carna4 incorporates these seeds as a source of vitamins, minerals, and other naturally occurring compounds rather than depending on a conventional vitamin and mineral premix.
Their recipes include ingredients like chicken liver, whole eggs, sprouted barley seeds, sprouted flaxseeds, and vegetables, depending on the formula. According to Carna4, this combination allows its finished food to meet nutritional requirements without adding isolated synthetic nutrients.
Another thing that makes Carna4 different is how they process their food. Rather than using traditional extrusion, they briefly bake it before air-drying it. According to Carna4, this process helps retain naturally occurring nutrients while producing a shelf-stable food.
What products do they offer?
Carna4 offers six dry dog food recipes: Chicken, Duck, Fish, Lamb, Venison, and Goat. Their Chicken and Duck formulas are the original recipes, while Fish, Lamb, Venison, and Goat come in an Easy-Chew format with smaller, softer nuggets. That could be a nice option for puppies, smaller breeds, senior dogs, or dogs that simply prefer a different texture.
They also offer complete dry foods for cats in chicken and fish recipes, along with Flora4 sprouted-seed meal toppers and other supplemental products. The Flora4 products are meant to complement an existing diet rather than replace a complete and balanced meal.
Where to Buy: Carna4 is available online through White Dog Bone and participating pet food retailers. Visit Carna4's Where to Buy page to find a retailer near you.
Winnie Lou
Winnie Lou is a Colorado-based pet food company with a pretty fun origin story! The company started in 2018 as a food truck for dogs, selling homemade treats made with ingredients sourced from the Boulder Farmers Market. What began as a small business inspired by the founders' own dogs, Winston and Louis, eventually grew into a nationwide pet treat brand, and they've now expanded into complete air-dried dog food.
Their philosophy has always centered around clean, recognizable ingredients and transparency about what goes into their products. Their new air-dried recipes follow that same approach, using whole-food ingredients and low-temperature drying to create a shelf-stable food without relying on a conventional vitamin and mineral premix. I also like their emphasis on responsibly sourced proteins, including wild-caught whitefish alongside less-common options like bison, lamb, and venison.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
Winnie Lou works with board-certified veterinary nutritionists to formulate recipes that meet AAFCO nutritional requirements for all life stages. Their approach combines muscle meat, organs, ground bone, seafood, seeds, and produce to supply essential nutrients.
One particularly interesting aspect of their formulations is the variety of animal ingredients they use. Their Turkey & Whitefish recipe combines turkey meat, liver, heart, and wild-caught whitefish, while Surf & Turf incorporates venison, lamb liver, and bison organs. These ingredients provide different combinations of amino acids, vitamins, and minerals, while ground bone contributes calcium and phosphorus. They also use ingredients like kelp, flaxseed, and Brazil nuts in select recipes to provide additional nutrients.
It's worth noting that their Surf & Turf recipe lists added zinc, while Turkey & Whitefish and Bison & Lamb don't list any added vitamins or minerals. I appreciate that Winnie Lou publishes its ingredient lists and nutritional information, making it easier to see how the different recipes are formulated.
What products do they offer?
Winnie Lou currently offers three gently air-dried dog food recipes: Surf & Turf, Turkey & Whitefish, and Bison & Lamb. Turkey & Whitefish is grain-free, while the other two contain grains like millet and oats. They also offer a sampler pack, which could be a nice way to try the different proteins before purchasing a larger bag.
Where to Buy: Available directly through Winnie Lou's website.
Disclosure: Winnie Lou provided complimentary products for this article.
Sundays Food for Dogs
Sundays is a veterinarian-founded pet food company created by Dr. Tory Waxman and her husband, Michael, who wanted to make feeding dogs healthier food a whole lot easier. Their goal was to create something with the nutritional appeal of home-cooked meals but the convenience of kibble. After experimenting with different preparation methods, they settled on gently air-drying whole-food ingredients to create a complete diet that doesn't require refrigeration, thawing, or meal preparation.
I think that's a pretty practical philosophy, especially for people who want to feed fresh, recognizable ingredients but don't have the freezer space or time for preparing meals every day. Their food is also human-grade and formulated with an emphasis on animal-based ingredients.
When I opened the bag, the first thing I noticed was the texture. Instead of the hard, crunchy pieces you'd expect from kibble, Sundays comes in small, chewy pieces that remind me of beef jerky. The bag is resealable, too, which makes it easy to keep the food stored between meals.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
Sundays combines animal proteins, organs, and other nutrient-rich ingredients to provide essential vitamins and minerals without relying on an extensive synthetic premix. Their recipes are formulated by veterinarians and veterinary nutritionists to meet AAFCO nutritional requirements for all life stages, including the growth of large-breed puppies.
Their Chicken Recipe, for example, includes chicken, chicken liver, eggs, ground bone, millet, oats, pumpkin, kale, and fish oil. The liver and eggs contribute vitamins and minerals, ground bone provides calcium and phosphorus, and fish oil supplies omega-3 fatty acids. The company also incorporates fruits, vegetables, and seeds to contribute additional nutrients.
Another important part of their approach is how they process the food. Rather than using traditional high-temperature kibble extrusion, Sundays gently cooks and air-dries its recipes to reduce moisture and make them shelf-stable. Their Beef and Fish recipes do contain added selenium in the form of selenium yeast, but they don't use a conventional vitamin and mineral premix.
What products do they offer?
Sundays offers four air-dried dog food recipes: Beef, Chicken, Turkey, and Fish. Their Beef Recipe is particularly meat-heavy, while Chicken is a leaner option. Fish features proteins like silver carp and salmon, providing naturally occurring omega-3 fatty acids.
They also offer Small Bites for dogs that prefer smaller pieces. Everything can be served straight from the package, making it an especially convenient option for people interested in whole-food nutrition without the extra preparation.
Where to Buy: Available directly through Sundays Food for Dogs' website. Click link to get 50% off your first order.
Yumwoof
Yumwoof offers several air-dried dog foods, but it's their Ancestral Blend line that caught my attention. These recipes are made with a variety of meats, organs, and other animal-based ingredients, without using synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes. They're also quite calorie-dense, which is something worth paying attention to when figuring out feeding portions!
I received a 7 lb bag with the older Perfect Superfood branding, which is the previous name for Ancestral Blend. One thing I wasn't thrilled about was that the bag isn't resealable. That's a minor inconvenience, but with an air-dried food you're opening regularly, I really do prefer a built-in closure. I can't say whether they've changed that on the newer packaging.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
Yumwoof's Ancestral Blend recipes use a combination of muscle meats, organ meats, fish, eggs, and naturally occurring fats to supply essential nutrients. Their Land & Sea formula is particularly interesting because it incorporates several animal protein sources, including turkey, pork, duck, fish, and eggs, rather than relying on a single primary protein.
According to Yumwoof, these recipes are formulated to meet AAFCO nutrient profiles for all life stages, including the growth of large-breed puppies, without synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes. Their approach focuses heavily on animal-based nutrition, with organ meats providing many of the vitamins and minerals that other brands might add individually.
Another thing worth mentioning is how calorie-dense these foods are. The Land & Sea recipe lists approximately 659 calories per cup, considerably more concentrated than many conventional kibbles. That means feeding portions may look surprisingly small, even for larger dogs, so it's important to follow the calorie information rather than simply feeding the same number of cups as a previous food.
What products do they offer?
Yumwoof currently offers three Ancestral Blend recipes: Land & Sea, Wild Caught Fish, and Turkey. Land & Sea contains the broadest variety of animal proteins, Wild Caught Fish offers a fish-focused formula, and Turkey is their lowest-fat Ancestral Blend option. The food is shelf-stable and available in different bag sizes.
The company also offers a softer, chewy air-dried food under its Perfect Kibble/Original Recipe line, with chicken and beef options. However, there's an important distinction between the two lines. Unlike Ancestral Blend, these recipes list a much more extensive collection of added vitamins and minerals, including vitamins E, D3, B1, B2, and B12, along with iron, copper, manganese, zinc, and other nutrients.
Because this article focuses on foods with minimal or no added vitamin and mineral premixes, Ancestral Blend is the Yumwoof product line I'm featuring here, rather than their entire range. Two product lines from the same brand can take very different approaches to achieving complete and balanced nutrition, so I think that's an important distinction to make.
Where to Buy: Available directly through Yumwoof's website. Use code JAKOBA for 5% off
Best Whole-Food-Based Fresh & Gently Cooked Pet Foods
Fresh and gently cooked foods offer another approach to whole-food nutrition, with ingredients that often look much more like something you'd prepare in your own kitchen. These companies typically use combinations of meat, organs, vegetables, and other nutrient-dense ingredients, then cook them at controlled temperatures before freezing or refrigerating.
One thing I appreciate about this category is that it offers a middle ground between traditional kibble and raw feeding. You get the convenience of a prepared, complete and balanced meal without handling raw meat at feeding time.
Evermore
Evermore is an independently owned, women-owned pet food company that's been making gently cooked dog food since 2009, and they expanded into cat food in 2025. Their meals are made with human-grade ingredients, including responsibly raised meats, organs, eggs, and organic produce. One thing that caught my attention is how transparent they are about their food. They share information about their ingredient suppliers, publish detailed nutritional analyses, and test their food rather than relying entirely on calculated nutrient values.
They use a sous-vide cooking process, which involves sealing the ingredients in pouches and gently cooking them before freezing. This allows the food to retain its natural moisture and cooking juices.
I was really impressed when I opened Evermore. The food looks and smells like meat and vegetables, with finely ground meat, tiny visible pieces of orange and green vegetables, and a nice amount of broth. It's exactly what I'd expect from a gently cooked meal. Even better, Roman, who can be notoriously picky, absolutely loved it! One thing worth knowing is that their pouches are designed to be cut open with scissors rather than peeled apart, so you'll want to have a pair handy when preparing meals.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
Evermore relies primarily on nutrient-rich whole foods, including muscle meats, hearts, livers, eggs, vegetables, seeds, and oils, to meet nutritional requirements. Their Chicken Recipe contains chicken, chicken hearts, chicken livers, eggs, organic sweet potatoes, carrots, kale, apples, blueberries, pumpkin seeds, eggshell powder, and pollock oil, among other ingredients.
Their dog recipes do contain one added mineral: zinc gluconate. That's an important distinction because Evermore doesn't use a traditional vitamin and mineral premix, but it does supplement this specific nutrient. The majority of its nutritional formulation still comes from whole-food ingredients, which fits what we're looking for in this article.
Evermore also tests every batch of food before releasing it, checking for pathogens, nutritional composition, and mineral levels. They regularly test additional nutrients, including vitamins, amino acids, and fatty acids, which I especially appreciate in a food that relies so heavily on naturally occurring nutrients.
What products do they offer?
Evermore offers four gently cooked dog food recipes: Chicken, Beef, Turkey, and Lamb. All four are formulated to meet AAFCO nutritional requirements for adult maintenance, so they aren't intended as complete diets for growing puppies.
They also offer gently cooked cat food in Beef and Turkey recipes, both formulated for all life stages. Unlike their dog recipes, these contain added vitamin E and thiamine. Their product lineup also includes Evermorsels, single-ingredient freeze-dried treats.
Where to Buy: Available through Evermore's website and select independent retailers.
Disclosure: Evermore provided complimentary products for this article.
Raised Right
Raised Right is a family-owned company that makes gently cooked, human-grade foods for dogs and cats. Their recipes are particularly high in protein and low in carbohydrates, with relatively short ingredient lists. Many contain less than 2% carbohydrates as fed, which is considerably lower than most traditional kibble.
I tried their gently cooked cat food with Dorian, and he really likes it! The texture was different from what I expected, though. It's extremely finely ground and uniformly brown, with no distinguishable vegetable pieces or other ingredients. To me it looks more like a traditional canned food than a typical gently cooked meal, and it feels a little drier than I'd expect. It also has very little noticeable odor compared with Evermore. None of that seems to bother Dorian, though!
Another thing worth mentioning is their food safety testing. Raised Right cooks its meals in a USDA-inspected facility and tests every batch for pathogens before releasing it for sale. They also make those results available to customers, which is a nice level of transparency.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
Raised Right's Original Adult Dog recipes are a great example of how a relatively short list of whole-food ingredients can provide complete and balanced nutrition without synthetic vitamin and mineral supplements.
Their Original Turkey Recipe, for example, contains turkey thigh, turkey heart, turkey liver, carrots, blueberries, organic spearmint, cod liver oil, eggshell powder, flaxseed oil, and dried kelp. That's the entire ingredient list! The organs provide a variety of naturally occurring vitamins and minerals, while ingredients like eggshell powder supply calcium and cod liver oil contributes omega-3 fatty acids and fat-soluble vitamins.
However, not all of Raised Right's recipes use the same approach. Their puppy formulas include targeted additions such as zinc, copper, and dicalcium phosphate to help meet the nutritional requirements of growing dogs. Their cat recipes include taurine and thiamine, while some newer formulas also contain supplemental zinc and manganese.
What products do they offer?
Raised Right offers gently cooked adult dog foods in Beef, Chicken, Turkey, and Pork, along with several pâté-style recipes containing pumpkin. They also have dedicated puppy recipes formulated for growth, including large-breed puppies.
Their cat food lineup includes several adult recipes featuring proteins like chicken, turkey, and pork, along with pâté options. They also offer veterinary support recipes with modified nutrient levels, including lower-fat and lower-phosphorus formulas.
The meals are shipped frozen, and customers can select different recipes within their orders. That variety could be especially convenient for people who like rotating proteins rather than feeding the same recipe every day.
Where to Buy: Available directly through Raised Right's website. Use code PETS20 for 20% off your first order
Allprovide
Allprovide is a small-batch pet food company based in Georgia that's been producing fresh, whole-food-based diets since 2014. They offer both raw and gently cooked foods for dogs and cats, with a philosophy centered around using nutrition to support overall health and well-being. One thing I appreciate is their goal of making fresh, nutrient-dense food more accessible and affordable, rather than treating it exclusively as a luxury product.
I really liked the texture of Allprovide's gently cooked food. It's very meaty, with small pieces of vegetables mixed throughout, rather than the overly processed or mushy consistency you sometimes see with fresh foods. Runa absolutely loved it, too! She had no hesitation digging right in.
Something that makes Allprovide particularly interesting is their collaboration with integrative veterinarian Dr. Judy Morgan. Together, they've developed specialty diets inspired by Traditional Chinese Veterinary Medicine (TCVM), which takes a holistic approach to health and incorporates food therapy. In this system, foods are traditionally categorized by properties such as warming, cooling, and neutral, with different ingredients selected according to an animal's individual needs. It's certainly a different approach to pet nutrition! While these traditional classifications aren't established nutritional requirements, I find the philosophy interesting, particularly alongside the company's emphasis on complete and balanced whole-food diets.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
Allprovide builds its recipes around combinations of muscle meat, organ meats, finely ground bone, vegetables, and other nutrient-dense ingredients. Their approach emphasizes using different parts of the animal to provide essential nutrients, rather than relying heavily on isolated supplements.
Ground bone supplies calcium and phosphorus, while organ meats like liver and heart contribute nutrients such as iron, copper, vitamin A, and B vitamins. Their recipes also include ingredients like kale, spinach, carrots, and butternut squash, depending on the formula. Allprovide provides a breakdown of how different ingredients contribute nutritionally, which I appreciate because it helps explain why they're included.
Their gently cooked recipes are prepared using low-temperature steaming before being frozen, and the company states that its complete dog meals meet AAFCO nutritional requirements for all life stages. The standard meals follow a more conventional whole-food formulation, while Dr. Judy Morgan's specialty recipes incorporate additional food-therapy principles. I think it's worth distinguishing those two approaches rather than assuming every Allprovide recipe is formulated around TCVM.
What products do they offer?
Allprovide offers four standard gently cooked dog recipes: Beef, Chicken, Pork, and Turkey, along with Dr. Judy Morgan's Puploaf. Their food comes frozen in 1 lb packages, and they also offer raw and ready-to-cook options.
Their gently cooked cat food line includes Beef, Chicken, Turkey, and CatLoaf. The company also offers specialty diets developed with Dr. Judy Morgan using traditional food-therapy principles, as well as supplemental products like bone broths.
I really like that Allprovide offers several preparation options. Having raw, ready-to-cook, and gently cooked foods from the same company could be especially convenient for households with different feeding preferences.
Where to Buy: Available directly through Allprovide's website. Get 5% off through this link
Identity Pet Nutrition
Identity Pet Nutrition offers several types of pet food, but their imagine Gently Cooked line is what caught my attention for this article. These frozen, human-grade meals are made with 95% animal-based ingredients and surprisingly short ingredient lists. Unlike many other fresh pet foods, they don't rely on synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes, grains, potatoes, or legumes.
One thing that stands out to me is how meat-heavy these recipes are. Many gently cooked foods contain substantial amounts of vegetables or starches, while Identity uses a much higher proportion of animal ingredients. That doesn't automatically make it a better food, but it's certainly a different approach to formulating a complete diet.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
Identity's imagine recipes use muscle meat, organs, and smaller amounts of fruits, vegetables, oils, and other whole-food ingredients to provide essential nutrients without a synthetic premix. For example, their 95% Beef Recipe contains beef, beef heart, carrots, spinach, butternut squash, apples, blueberries, organic coconut oil, turmeric, cinnamon, dried eggshell, and sea salt. There are no added synthetic vitamins or minerals listed. Dried eggshell supplies calcium, while meat and organs contribute many of the other nutrients needed in a balanced diet.
Identity markets these recipes as complete and balanced meals for adult dogs. I also appreciate that they provide detailed nutrient analyses alongside their recipes, which is especially useful when comparing foods made with such different ingredient combinations.
Identity's gently cooked cat recipes follow a similar whole-food approach, although some contain added taurine, an essential amino acid for cats. Unlike a traditional vitamin or mineral supplement, taurine is an amino acid, but it's still a separately added nutrient rather than one supplied entirely by the other food ingredients.
What products do they offer?
Identity currently offers six imagine Gently Cooked dog recipes: Chicken, Turkey, Beef, Pork, Bison, and Rabbit. I think that's a pretty impressive protein selection, particularly since bison and rabbit aren't nearly as common as chicken or beef in fresh dog food.
They also offer a Rotation Box containing multiple proteins, as well as a separate believe Bland Diets line with Chicken & Rice and Beef & Rice recipes. Unlike their imagine formulas, the bland diets contain approximately 70% meat and 30% rice.
Identity also has gently cooked cat recipes featuring Chicken, Turkey, Beef, Pork, Bison, and Rabbit.
Beyond their gently cooked foods, Identity has an extensive selection of canned pâté recipes for both dogs and cats, including less-common proteins like quail and rabbit. These foods are also meat-heavy, but unlike their imagine Gently Cooked line, the canned recipes contain added vitamins and minerals. Identity uses nutrient blends tailored to individual recipes, so while they take a different approach to supplementation, they're still an interesting option for people looking for high-meat-content canned foods.
Where to Buy: Available through Identity Pet Nutrition's website
Leaps for Dogs
Leaps for Dogs is a gently cooked dog food company with one of the most interesting nutritional philosophies I've come across. Their recipes were developed specifically with dogs battling cancer in mind, focusing on nutritional challenges like inflammation, muscle loss, and changes in metabolism. While their approach was designed around cancer nutrition, their food is also complete and balanced for healthy adult dogs.
This brand is especially meaningful to me because I've had two dogs battle cancer in the past two years. Koba was diagnosed with bladder cancer in 2024, and Ryker battled an aggressive form of cancer that originated from a mammary tumor. During Ryker's treatment, I spent a lot of time researching nutrition and exploring different dietary approaches that might help support her. I really wish I'd known about Leaps back then, because it's absolutely a food I would have considered trying with both of them.
What makes Leaps different is how their cancer-focused philosophy influences their formulations. They prioritize high-quality animal proteins to help maintain muscle mass, healthy fats with an emphasis on omega-3 fatty acids, and very low carbohydrate levels, with less than 10% of calories coming from carbohydrates. They also maintain an omega-6 to omega-3 ratio below 2:1. Their low-carbohydrate approach is partly inspired by research into cancer metabolism, although restricting carbohydrates hasn't been proven to prevent or slow cancer in dogs.
Another thoughtful detail is their decision to gently cook their food rather than serve it raw. This is particularly relevant for dogs undergoing cancer treatment, as some may have compromised immune systems and be more vulnerable to foodborne illness.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
Leaps takes a very intentional approach to ingredient selection, choosing nutrient-dense whole foods that serve multiple nutritional purposes. Rather than simply combining meat and vegetables, they select ingredients that provide essential vitamins and minerals while also supporting their broader nutritional philosophy.
For example, organ meats like bison liver provide naturally occurring vitamin A, B vitamins, and iron, while oysters contribute important trace minerals such as zinc and copper. Sardines and other fish supply EPA and DHA omega-3 fatty acids, which are particularly interesting given the company's focus on inflammation. They also incorporate ingredients like wheat germ oil for vitamin E, chia seeds for minerals and fiber, and maitake mushrooms for their beta-glucans, compounds being studied for potential immune-supporting properties.
I think what's particularly interesting is how they bring all of these ingredients together to create a complete diet without relying on a synthetic vitamin and mineral premix, while still maintaining their specific protein, fat, and carbohydrate targets. Their recipes are formulated to meet AAFCO nutrient profiles for adult maintenance, and Leaps publishes detailed nutritional analyses showing individual vitamin and mineral levels, fatty acid profiles, and other nutritional information. I really appreciate this transparency, especially from a company with such a specific nutritional philosophy.
What products do they offer?
Leaps offers three gently cooked recipes featuring combinations of beef, turkey, whitefish, sardines, vegetables, and other nutrient-dense ingredients. Each follows their high-protein, low-carbohydrate approach, with different nutritional profiles to accommodate different needs, including dogs struggling to maintain weight or those needing leaner proteins.
Their food arrives frozen in vacuum-sealed packages and is available in several portion sizes. All three recipes are formulated for adult maintenance rather than puppy growth.
Where to buy: Available directly through Leaps' website. Use code JAKOBA for 20% off your first order
Disclosure: Leaps provided complimentary products for this article.
Best Whole-Food-Based Raw & Freeze-Dried Pet Foods
Interestingly, I found more whole-food-based options in the raw and freeze-dried category than anywhere else! I think part of the reason is that these foods can incorporate ingredients like raw organs, ground bone, seafood, and other nutrient-rich foods without the high-temperature processing used to manufacture traditional kibble. This gives manufacturers more flexibility to formulate diets around naturally occurring nutrients, although achieving the proper nutritional balance still requires careful formulation.
Many of these companies also offer freeze-dried versions of their foods, which remove moisture without the high temperatures of conventional cooking. This makes them shelf-stable while retaining many of the characteristics of raw food. Of course, raw feeding does require additional attention to food safety, and freeze-drying alone doesn't eliminate the risk of harmful bacteria.
Viva Raw
When I imported my German Shepherd puppy, Runa, earlier this year, I knew I wanted to feed her a diet formulated primarily with whole-food ingredients. Viva Raw was one of the few raw food brands I found that offered a dedicated puppy recipe formulated for the growth of large-breed dogs, and that's what Runa has eaten almost exclusively for the past four months. Overall, I think it's a fantastic food, and she's done incredibly well on it!
The food itself comes in relatively thin, flat packages, so it thaws quickly, which I really appreciate. It does have a stronger smell than some other raw brands I've tried, but not in a bad way. Runa absolutely loves it, and my other dogs are always trying to sneak a taste! I've also appreciated Viva's willingness to help me figure out how to incorporate different proteins into her diet. Their team provided guidance on balancing other recipes for puppies, which is fantastic because I love rotating proteins with my dogs.
We also brought home a Maine Coon kitten, Dorian, a few months ago and immediately started him on Viva Raw's cat food. He's a little pickier than Runa and doesn't seem to care for the turkey recipe, but he's loved every other protein we've tried, just as much as canned food! Both Runa and Dorian have been gaining weight steadily without growing too quickly, have beautiful, healthy coats, and plenty of energy. Their stools have also been consistently small and noticeably less smelly, which is always a nice bonus.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
Viva Raw relies primarily on nutrient-rich whole foods to provide essential vitamins and minerals, rather than using an extensive synthetic premix. Their Beef & Turkey puppy recipe, for example, contains 90% animal ingredients, 5% organic fruits and vegetables, and 5% natural supplements. Alongside meat, organs, and ground bone, they use ingredients like mussels, oysters, fish oil, kelp, cod liver oil, and shiitake mushrooms to provide nutrients that growing puppies need.
I especially appreciate that they've paid attention to the nutritional requirements of large-breed puppies. Their puppy formula is designed with appropriate calcium and phosphorus levels and is formulated to meet the AAFCO nutrient profiles for growth, including large-breed dogs expected to weigh 70 pounds or more as adults. That's an important distinction because not every food labeled for puppies is suitable for large-breed growth.
Viva does use some targeted supplementation, including vitamin E in their puppy recipe and manganese proteinate and taurine in their cat recipes. Taurine is particularly important for cats, so I appreciate that they account for those nutritional needs.
What products do they offer?
Viva Raw offers complete and balanced frozen raw foods for adult dogs, puppies, and cats. Their adult dog recipes include proteins such as beef, chicken, turkey, duck, pork, and rabbit, with ground and chunky textures available for many of them. The puppy line features a Beef & Turkey formula specifically designed for growth, while their cat recipes include chicken, turkey, beef, duck, and rabbit and are formulated for all life stages, including kittens.
They also offer Pure formulas, which are simpler meat, organ, and bone blends intended for people who prefer to build their own meals. Unlike their complete recipes, Pure formulas aren't nutritionally complete on their own. I appreciate that Viva provides detailed guidance on which nutrients need to be added to balance these recipes for dogs, puppies, and cats. This is also the guidance their team helped me with when I wanted more protein variety for Runa.
Another thing worth mentioning is their approach to food safety. Viva uses lot testing for pathogens and has introduced high-pressure processing (HPP), a cold-pressure method intended to reduce harmful bacteria without cooking the food. According to Viva, the transition began in January 2026, and products with best-by dates of March 15, 2027 or later have undergone HPP. It's an additional safety measure, although it doesn't eliminate the need to handle raw food carefully.
Overall, Viva Raw has become one of my favorite options for feeding both dogs and cats. I've especially appreciated having complete, whole-food-based recipes for two growing animals with very different nutritional needs. Between the ingredient quality, convenient packaging, variety of proteins, and how well Runa and Dorian have done on the food, it's definitely a brand I feel comfortable recommending.
Where to Buy: Available directly through Viva Raw's website. Get 60% off your first order with code VONJAKOBA
Disclosure: I have an ongoing promotional partnership with Viva Raw through my social media channels. This article was written independently and is not sponsored by Viva Raw.
Answers Pet Food
Answers is a frozen raw pet food brand that uses nutrient-dense whole foods to create complete and balanced meals for dogs and cats. What really sets them apart is their focus on fermentation, which they use to support gut health, preserve their food, and, according to the company, help inhibit the growth of harmful bacteria.
I've fed Answers' raw patties to my dogs off and on over the years, usually in rotation with other brands, and we've always had a great experience with them. The quality has consistently been excellent, our dogs have always enjoyed eating it, and we've never had any issues with their stools. One thing I especially appreciate is how quickly the patties thaw. They're finely ground and easy to portion, which is a practical plus when feeding multiple large dogs!
Fermentation is a natural process involving beneficial microorganisms that break down components of food and produce compounds like lactic acid. According to Answers, their fermentation process helps make nutrients easier to digest and absorb while creating an environment that inhibits the growth of harmful bacteria. They also incorporate fermented ingredients like raw whey and cultured vegetables into their recipes. I think it's a pretty interesting approach to raw feeding, especially since fermentation is such a big part of their overall philosophy.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
Answers uses a combination of meat, organs, bone, and other nutrient-rich ingredients, including duck eggs, cod liver oil, fermented vegetables, and raw whey. Their approach is to provide essential nutrients through whole-food ingredients rather than relying heavily on synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes. Their Mighty Raw Turkey recipe also carries a nutritional adequacy statement indicating that it provides nutrition comparable to a product substantiated through AAFCO feeding trials.
I also appreciate their emphasis on ingredient sourcing. Answers uses USDA organic poultry, grass-fed and grass-finished beef, and responsibly raised pork, along with organic vegetables and other nutrient-rich ingredients. It's nice to see a company putting so much thought into where its ingredients come from, not just what's listed on the label.
What products do they offer?
Answers has two main frozen raw food lines for dogs: Mighty Raw and Simply Protein. Mighty Raw is their complete and balanced line, available in beef, chicken, turkey, and pork. It comes in several convenient formats, including nibbles, patties, and chubs. Simply Protein, on the other hand, is a limited-ingredient meat, organ, and bone base intended for people who prefer to customize their dog's meals. Unlike Mighty Raw, it isn't marketed as a complete and balanced diet on its own, so additional ingredients would be needed to create a nutritionally complete meal.
They also offer Mighty Raw formulas for cats, along with a variety of fermented products under their Power Pours line, including raw goat's milk, cow kefir, and fermented stocks. Their Good Energy line includes treats like raw goat cheese bites and fermented chicken feet. I think these additional products are worth mentioning because they make it easy to incorporate fermented foods into your pet's existing diet without necessarily switching their main food.
Overall, Answers is a brand I'd recommend looking into if you're interested in raw feeding, particularly if you like the idea of incorporating fermented foods into your dog's diet. Their approach is different from many other raw brands, and I appreciate that they offer both complete meals and products you can use alongside your current feeding routine.
Where to Buy: Available directly through Answers Pet Food's website, with nationwide shipping to the contiguous U.S., or through participating pet food retailers.
Disclosure: Answers Pet Food provided complimentary products for this article.
Bones & Co.
Bones & Co. is a family-owned raw pet food brand known for its meat-heavy, low-carbohydrate recipes. Their frozen raw and freeze-dried foods contain 95% meat, organs, and bone, with the remaining 5% consisting of vegetables and other ingredients. What really sets them apart is their focus on ketogenic-style nutrition, with their standard recipes containing less than 1% carbohydrates and a 1:1 fat-to-protein ratio.
We've tried their frozen raw Minis, and I've been really impressed with the quality! The dogs loved them, and I especially appreciate how quickly the smaller patties thaw. I'm also a big fan of their packaging. It's convenient, easy to store in the freezer, and makes portioning out meals pretty straightforward. Even though the Minis are marketed toward smaller dogs, they're also a nice option for larger dogs when you prefer thawing smaller portions rather than a large patty.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
Bones & Co. relies heavily on animal-based ingredients to provide essential nutrients, including muscle meat, organs, and ground bone. They also incorporate smaller amounts of organic vegetables, seeds, kelp, and oils to provide additional nutrients. For example, their Barkin' Beef recipe contains beef, heart, liver, kidney, ground bone, organic spinach, broccoli, squash, pumpkin seeds, flax seeds, fish oil, and cod liver oil.
Another interesting aspect of Bones & Co. is their emphasis on fat as an energy source. Their standard recipes are formulated with a roughly 1:1 fat-to-protein ratio, which is higher in fat than many other dog foods. They also go a step further with their packaging, listing dietary starch and sugar separately in the guaranteed analysis so customers can better understand the carbohydrate content. I appreciate that level of transparency, especially since carbohydrate information isn't always easy to find on pet food labels. Of course, higher-fat diets aren't necessarily appropriate for every dog, so that's something worth considering when comparing brands.
What products do they offer?
Bones & Co. offers five protein options in their frozen raw line: beef, chicken, duck, lamb, and turkey. Their food comes in several formats, including 1.5 oz Minis, 8 oz patties, smaller Bites, and larger bulk options. I really like that they offer different sizes depending on how many dogs you're feeding and how much food you need at a time.
They also offer complete and balanced freeze-dried raw meals in beef, chicken, and turkey. Their freeze-dried beef and chicken recipes are even available in larger 7 lb bags, which is a nice option for multiple-dog households. Beyond their complete meals, their lineup includes raw bones, treats, and supplements.
Overall, Bones & Co. is another raw food brand I've had a really positive experience with. I appreciate their straightforward ingredient lists, minimal supplementation, and the variety of feeding formats. Their Minis have been especially convenient for us, and I think they're worth considering if you're looking for a meat-heavy raw food with very few carbohydrates.
Where to Buy: Available through independent pet food retailers. Visit their Store Locator to find a retailer near you.
Disclosure: Bones & Co. provided complimentary products for this article.
Northwest Naturals
Northwest Naturals is an Oregon-based raw pet food company that's been producing frozen raw diets for decades. They offer both frozen and freeze-dried foods for dogs and cats, with a pretty impressive variety of proteins and feeding formats. But what really caught my attention is a recent change to their recipes: they've been replacing their synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes with whole-food ingredients!
The company began introducing its updated formulas in 2025, after receiving feedback from customers who wanted foods without synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes. According to Northwest Naturals, this was actually one of their most requested changes. I think it's fantastic to see an established raw food company making such a significant change to its formulations, particularly when so many commercial pet foods rely on premixes.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
According to Northwest Naturals, their new whole-food formulations continue to meet AAFCO nutritional standards without the traditional synthetic vitamin and mineral premix. Instead, they use a combination of muscle meats, organs, ground bone, fruits, vegetables, and other nutrient-rich ingredients to provide essential vitamins and minerals.
For example, their Chicken Recipe includes chicken, ground chicken bone, liver, gizzards, eggs, vegetables, flaxseed, salmon oil, and a variety of fruits. Ground bone provides calcium and phosphorus, while organs, eggs, and other ingredients contribute additional nutrients. The company also publishes detailed nutritional information for its recipes, including calcium, phosphorus, zinc, copper, and calorie content.
One important thing to know if you're purchasing Northwest Naturals: The company says products with a best-by date of October 1, 2026, or later contain the new whole-food formulations, even if they're still in older packaging. If you're specifically looking for the recipes without synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes, this is something I'd check before buying.
Northwest Naturals has also updated its feeding calculator to provide recommendations for individual recipes rather than relying on an average across their foods. That's worth checking if you're switching from one of their older formulas, since calorie content and recommended feeding amounts can vary.
What products do they offer?
Northwest Naturals offers a variety of frozen raw dog foods, including small nuggets, larger chubs, and bulk meal bars. Their frozen recipes include proteins like Beef, Chicken, Turkey, Lamb, Trout, Bison & Beef, and several combinations featuring fish. They also offer freeze-dried nuggets, which provide a shelf-stable alternative to their frozen meals.
One thing I like about their product selection is the variety of portion sizes. The smaller frozen nuggets are designed to thaw quickly, while their bulk meal bars are divided into convenient sections. Larger chubs are another option for people feeding big dogs or multiple dogs who go through quite a bit of food.
They also make raw foods for cats, including frozen and freeze-dried options, along with a variety of freeze-dried treats and toppers.
Something else worth mentioning is that not every dog recipe is formulated for the same life stages. For example, their Chicken and Turkey recipes are labeled for growth, including large-breed puppies, while some other formulas exclude the growth of dogs expected to weigh 70 pounds or more as adults. That's an important distinction, particularly if you're feeding a growing large-breed puppy like I am!
Where to Buy: Available through participating pet food retailers. Visit their Store Locator to find a retailer near you.
Disclosure: Northwest Naturals provided complimentary products for this article.
BJ's Raw
BJ's Raw is a Pennsylvania-based raw pet food company offering a huge variety of frozen raw foods, treats, chews, and supplements for dogs and cats. Their recipes focus heavily on meat, organs, and bone, without relying on traditional synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes. Many of their products follow the 80/10/10 prey-model raw approach, although they also offer more complex blends containing additional ingredients like salmon, vegetables, and bone broth.
We've been feeding BJ's Raw for about a year now, and it's become a regular part of our dogs' rotation! Most of my dogs love pretty much everything we've tried, although my pickier eaters definitely seem to prefer their red meat recipes over poultry. One thing I really appreciate is the variety. With multiple large dogs, I like being able to rotate different proteins, and BJ's offers plenty of options to choose from.
Another thing I love is their packaging. Their food comes frozen in tubs with resealable lids, which makes it easy to thaw and portion out what you need. They offer 2 lb and 10 lb tubs, along with larger 38 lb tubs for select recipes. Buying in bulk can make their food considerably more affordable, especially if you're feeding multiple dogs like I am. And if you're fortunate enough to live near their Lancaster, Pennsylvania, location, you can also purchase directly from them and potentially save even more!
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
BJ's Raw uses a whole-prey approach to nutrition, incorporating muscle meat, organ meats, and finely ground bone to provide naturally occurring vitamins and minerals. Many of their recipes follow an 80/10/10 ratio, meaning approximately 80% muscle meat, 10% bone, and 10% organs. Other recipes incorporate ingredients like whole salmon, beef tripe, vegetables, and bone broth for additional nutritional variety.
One important distinction is that an 80/10/10 ratio alone doesn't guarantee a food is nutritionally complete and balanced. While it's a popular starting point for raw feeding, some nutrients can still fall short depending on the ingredients used. BJ's offers several recipes marketed as complete and balanced, including their Premium Mix and Basic Mix. Their Premium Mix carries a nutritional adequacy statement substantiated through AAFCO feeding trials, while Basic Mix states that it provides nutrition comparable to a food substantiated through feeding trials. BJ's also sells individual protein blends and supplemental products, so I always recommend checking the AAFCO nutritional adequacy statement for the specific recipe you're considering rather than assuming every blend is suitable as a complete diet.
Their Premium Mix is particularly interesting because it combines chicken, beef, pork, and wild-caught Alaskan salmon with organ meats, bone, vegetables, and other whole-food ingredients. Rather than using a conventional synthetic vitamin and mineral premix, BJ's relies on these ingredients to provide essential nutrients.
What products do they offer?
BJ's Raw has an extensive selection of frozen raw foods, including blends featuring beef, chicken, turkey, duck, rabbit, goat, venison, and several other proteins. Their lineup includes complete meals, protein blends for people who prefer balancing their own raw diets, and specialty recipes with different ingredient combinations.
They also offer a wide selection of raw meaty bones, chews, organ meats, goat's milk, bone broth, and other supplemental products. I especially love their treats and chews, and it's nice being able to order those alongside our dogs' regular meals rather than shopping at several different places.
Where to Buy: Available directly through BJ's Raw Pet Food's website. Use our codes for 25% off and free shipping: JAKOBA25 and JAKOBASHIP
Disclosure: I have an ongoing promotional partnership with BJ’s Raw through my social media channels. This article was written independently and is not sponsored by BJ’s Raw.
Green Juju
Green Juju was founded in 2014 by Kelley Marian after her dog, Bailey, was diagnosed with a rare form of cancer. Wanting to improve Bailey's nutrition, Kelley began incorporating fresh, nutrient-dense foods into her diet, including leafy greens. What started as homemade vegetable blends eventually grew into Green Juju, a company offering complete raw diets, treats, toppers, and supplements for pets.
I've known about Green Juju for years and have always considered them one of the healthier pet food brands, but we only recently tried their freeze-dried raw food for the first time. I was really happy with the quality and ingredients, and our dogs absolutely loved it! I also appreciate their emphasis on responsibly sourced animal proteins and simple, recognizable ingredients.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
Green Juju relies on a combination of meat, nutrient-rich organs, bone, organic leafy greens, and kelp to provide essential vitamins and minerals naturally. Their original raw recipes have impressively short ingredient lists, with some containing just a handful of ingredients. For example, their Goat Recipe uses goat heart, goat with bone, liver, kidney, organic parsley, and kelp as its primary nutritional ingredients.
According to Green Juju, their complete raw diets are formulated to meet AAFCO nutritional standards for all life stages, including the growth of large-breed puppies. Some recipes have also undergone AAFCO feeding trials for adult maintenance, which is another positive. I particularly appreciate that they can achieve complete and balanced nutrition with such simple ingredient lists, without relying on a conventional vitamin and mineral premix.
What products do they offer?
Green Juju offers complete raw meals in both frozen and freeze-dried formats, with proteins including beef, pork, lamb, goat, and rabbit. They also have an Extras line featuring combinations like Chicken & Sardine, Turkey & Sardine, and Duck & Sardine, which incorporate a wider variety of organic fruits, vegetables, and other nutrient-dense ingredients.
Beyond their complete meals, they have quite a few other products worth checking out! Their Whole Food Bites were another big hit with our dogs. These combine animal proteins with colorful organic fruits and vegetables and are intended as treats or meal toppers, rather than complete meals. I really like the idea of incorporating these types of ingredients into treats, especially since it's an easy way to add some extra variety to their diet.
I was also really interested in their probiotic supplements. Their Farm, Soil, and Leaf formulas take an interesting approach by using naturally fermented whole-food sources to provide a diverse range of naturally occurring bacteria and yeasts, rather than relying on just a handful of isolated probiotic strains. I haven't tried these personally, but I thought the formulations looked really interesting! Green Juju also offers vegetable blends, fermented pastes, bone broths, raw goat's milk, and single-ingredient training treats.
Overall, Green Juju definitely lived up to the positive impression I've had of them for years. I love the simplicity of their complete raw recipes, and it's always a bonus when the dogs are just as enthusiastic about a food as I am!
Where to Buy: Available directly from Green Juju or through independent pet retailers. Visit their Where to Buy page to find a retailer near you.
Shepherd Boy Farms
Shepherd Boy Farms is a family-owned pet food company based in Indiana with a pretty interesting story. The business originally started as a goat farm, but everything changed when another pet food company approached founder Ashton Hood about supplying raw goat's milk. After learning more about its potential nutritional benefits and trying it with his own dog, he became interested in creating pet food products himself. What started with goat farming eventually grew into a company specializing in freeze-dried raw foods, treats, and goat's milk products for dogs and cats.
We actually tried Shepherd Boy Farms' dehydrated goat's milk products before they expanded into complete freeze-dried meals, and I thought they were such a neat idea! The milk comes in a bottle with the powder already inside, so all you have to do is add water, shake, and it's ready to serve. They also offer several varieties with added superfoods, which is a fun way to incorporate some extra variety into your dog's diet. I was really happy to see them venture into complete freeze-dried dog food, too!
That farming background is still a big part of the company's philosophy. Shepherd Boy Farms emphasizes whole-food ingredients, careful sourcing, and minimally processed nutrition. Their complete meals are freeze-dried rather than cooked, making them shelf-stable without requiring the freezer space or thawing associated with frozen raw food. They also offer an unusually large variety of proteins, including some you rarely see in commercial dog food, like kangaroo and alligator!
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
Shepherd Boy Farms uses combinations of muscle meat, organ meats, raw goat's milk, and organic fruits and vegetables to provide essential nutrients. Their recipes are formulated without conventional synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes, relying on the nutrients naturally present in these ingredients.
Raw goat's milk is one of their signature ingredients, and I think it's especially interesting given the company's origins. It contributes protein, fat, calcium, and other nutrients, while organ meats supply essential vitamins and minerals. The company also emphasizes the naturally occurring microorganisms in raw goat's milk, although the amount that remains viable after freeze-drying and the specific benefits in the finished food aren't established.
Another important part of their approach is manufacturing and food safety. Shepherd Boy Farms produces its freeze-dried foods in its own Indiana facility and reports using independent laboratory testing before releasing batches for sale. Their complete recipes are formulated to meet AAFCO nutritional requirements, although life-stage suitability varies between formulas. For example, some recipes aren't appropriate for the growth of large-breed puppies, so it's important to check the individual nutritional adequacy statement.
What products do they offer?
Shepherd Boy Farms offers nine freeze-dried raw dog food recipes, including Beef, Chicken, Pork, Bison, Fish, Rabbit, Venison, Kangaroo, and Alligator. That's a pretty impressive variety, particularly for people who like rotating proteins or need something less commonly available.
They also offer freeze-dried cat foods, single-ingredient treats, organ meats, and several goat's milk products. Their goat's milk blends can be used as supplemental additions to an existing diet rather than replacing complete meals.
Where to Buy: Available directly through Shepherd Boy Farms' website and select retailers. Visit their Retail Locations page to find a retailer near you.
Disclosure: Shepherd Boy Farms provided complimentary products for this article.
Solutions Pet Products
Solutions Pet Products is a raw pet food company known for its high-fat, low-carbohydrate diets made with fermented whole-food ingredients. Like Answers Pet Food, Solutions incorporates fermentation into its recipes, using ingredients like raw milk and fermented eggs alongside pasture-raised meats, organ meats, and organic produce. Their emphasis on regenerative farming and thoughtful ingredient sourcing is another aspect of the company I appreciate.
I was first introduced to Solutions when my dog Ryker was diagnosed with mammary cancer. A friend of mine who's really into natural approaches to dog health recommended the brand, and we ended up following their Cancer & Metabolism Restorative Health Guide for a while. The guide outlines ketogenic feeding protocols using their Beef and Pork recipes, Better Butter Tea, gelatin broths, and additional fat sources to create a high-fat, very low-carbohydrate diet.
Diets like these have gained popularity among some owners of dogs with cancer because of the Warburg effect, which describes how many cancer cells rely heavily on glucose for energy. This has led to the theory that restricting carbohydrates could potentially interfere with tumor growth, although there's currently insufficient evidence that ketogenic diets improve cancer outcomes in dogs. Solutions' complete raw recipes contain approximately 1–2% carbohydrates and have a roughly 1:1 fat-to-protein ratio by weight, making them particularly calorie-dense. While this approach isn't appropriate for every dog, it's one of the things that distinguishes Solutions from many other raw food brands.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
Solutions relies on a combination of muscle meats, organs, bone, fermented dairy, eggs, and other nutrient-rich whole foods rather than a traditional synthetic vitamin and mineral premix. Unlike the common 80/10/10 approach to raw feeding, their recipes contain a much higher proportion of organ meats, generally around 25%, along with approximately 10% bone.
Their Beef Recipe includes grass-fed beef, heart, liver, kidney, bone, raw sheep's milk, fermented duck eggs, organic greens, sprouted chia seeds, fermented cod liver, and other whole-food ingredients. These ingredients provide a variety of naturally occurring vitamins and minerals, with organs playing a particularly important role in the nutritional formulation.
Fermentation is another major part of their approach. The company incorporates fermented ingredients such as eggs, vegetables, and dairy, which contribute to the food's nutritional composition. According to Solutions, fermentation also helps preserve the food and supports digestion. Their recipes are formulated and tested to meet AAFCO nutritional requirements, although I always recommend checking the nutritional adequacy statement for the specific recipe and life stage you're feeding.
What products do they offer?
Solutions currently offers four complete raw dog food recipes: Chicken, Beef, Pork, and Duck. They also have separate complete diets for cats, including Chicken and Pork.
Their foods come in several formats, including smaller portions and larger bulk boxes, with 12 lb and 20 lb options available for certain recipes. That's particularly helpful when feeding multiple large dogs, especially considering how quickly smaller packages of frozen raw food can disappear!
Beyond their complete raw diets, Solutions offers some pretty unique products you don't often see from pet food companies. Their Jiggles are gelatin-rich broths available in different proteins, while Better Butter Tea combines fermented raw goat milk, butter, and herbs. They also offer GOATnog, Tummy Butter Kefir Tea, fermented cheeses, and other specialty products. I love seeing options like these for people who want to incorporate more whole foods into their pets' diets without necessarily changing their main food.
Where to Buy: Available through participating retailers. Visit their Where to Buy page to find purchasing options.
The Simple Food Project
The Simple Food Project is an independently owned, veterinarian-founded pet food company created by Dr. Chris Bessent. Their focus is on making freeze-dried raw food more accessible without sacrificing ingredient quality. Everything is made in their own Wisconsin facility using whole-food ingredients, with no conventional synthetic vitamin and mineral premixes.
One thing I really like about their approach is the texture of their food. Rather than making everything into identical-looking nuggets, their dog recipes combine freeze-dried and air-dried pieces with visible bits of organs, fruits, and vegetables. The idea is to offer some variety in each bowl while keeping the convenience of a shelf-stable food. That convenience is a huge plus, especially for anyone interested in raw feeding who doesn't want to deal with freezer space or thawing meals.
Their recipes are also relatively low in carbohydrates and contain around 70–80% meat and organs for dogs, with an even higher percentage of animal ingredients in their cat foods. They use ingredients like grass-fed beef, wild-caught fish, organic produce, and krill, with an emphasis on sourcing and keeping their formulas relatively simple.
So, how do they make their food complete and balanced?
The Simple Food Project relies on nutrient-dense whole foods to provide essential vitamins and minerals rather than adding a traditional premix. Their recipes combine muscle meat, organ meats, and other ingredients such as ground bone, pumpkin seeds, flaxseed, kelp, and krill.
For example, their Beef & Salmon Recipe contains beef, salmon, beef liver, beef heart, organic carrots, cranberries, ground krill, pumpkin seeds, spinach, and other whole-food ingredients. Krill is a particularly interesting addition because it contributes omega-3 fatty acids, while organ meats and seeds help supply other important nutrients.
I also appreciate that the company publishes independent nutritional analyses of its recipes and tests every batch. They use a low-temperature pasteurization process as an additional food safety measure, rather than high-pressure processing (HPP).
What products do they offer?
The Simple Food Project offers several freeze-dried raw dog food recipes, including Beef & Salmon, Chicken & Turkey, Duck & Trout, Bison, Lamb, and Duck. They also make complete cat foods in Chicken & Turkey, Salmon & Chicken, and Whitefish & Duck varieties.
Something particularly interesting is their Puppy Balancer, a whole-food-based supplement designed to make certain recipes nutritionally appropriate for growing puppies. Their Duck Recipe is formulated for all life stages without the balancer, while other recipes have specific feeding instructions depending on a puppy's expected adult size. This is especially important for large-breed puppies, since their nutritional requirements differ from those of smaller dogs.
They also offer single-ingredient freeze-dried treats, along with sample packs that make it easy to try different recipes before committing to a larger order.
Overall, I think The Simple Food Project is an interesting option for anyone who likes the idea of raw feeding but wants something easier to store, portion, and travel with. Their whole-food formulation, visible ingredients, and focus on making freeze-dried food more affordable are what stand out to me most.
Where to Buy: Available directly through The Simple Food Project's website. Use our code JAKOBA for 20% off your first order
Disclosure: The Simple Food Project provided complimentary products for this article.
Which Whole-Food Pet Foods Are Suitable for Puppies?
Puppies have different nutritional requirements from adult dogs, which means not every complete and balanced dog food is suitable for growth. Thankfully, several of the brands featured in this article offer recipes formulated for puppies or all life stages.
Whole-food-based brands offering puppy or all-life-stages recipes include:
Nature's Logic — All recipes
Carna4 — All recipes
Winnie Lou — All recipes
Sundays Food for Dogs — All recipes
Yumwoof — Ancestral Blend recipes
Raised Right — Puppy Growth recipes
Allprovide — All recipes
Viva Raw — Beef & Turkey Puppy Recipe
Answers Pet Food — Mighty Raw recipes
Bones & Co. — All recipes
Northwest Naturals — All recipes
BJ's Raw — Select complete meals, including Premium Mix, Basic Mix, Puppy Mix and others
Solutions Pet Products - All recipes
Green Juju - All recipes
Shepherd Boy Farms — All recipes
The Simple Food Project — All six recipes, with Puppy Balancer required for certain recipes depending on the puppy's age and expected adult size.
Keep in mind that some of these brands also offer adult-maintenance formulas or supplemental products, so it's important to check the specific recipe rather than assuming everything they sell is suitable for puppies.
What about Large-Breed Puppies?
This is something I paid especially close attention to when choosing food for Runa! Large-breed puppies have specific nutritional requirements, particularly when it comes to calcium and phosphorus, to support healthy bone development. Not every food formulated for puppies or all life stages meets these requirements, so it's important to pay attention to the nutritional adequacy statement.
The following foods include large-breed puppy growth in their published nutritional adequacy information:
Carna4 – All recipes
Sundays Food for Dogs – All recipes
Yumwoof – Ancestral Blend recipes
Raised Right – Puppy Growth recipes
Viva Raw – Beef & Turkey Puppy Recipe
Northwest Naturals – Select recipes, including Chicken, Turkey, Beef & Trout, and Trout
Green Juju - All recipes
The Simple Food Project — All six dog recipes: Duck on its own, or Beef & Salmon, Chicken & Turkey, Duck & Trout, Bison, and Lamb with Puppy Balancer.
This isn't necessarily an exhaustive list, as other brands featured in this article may offer suitable formulas. Always check the nutritional adequacy statement for the specific recipe you're considering.
One important thing to remember: A food doesn't have to be labeled specifically as “puppy food” to be appropriate for puppies. Many all-life-stages diets also meet the nutritional requirements for growth. For large-breed puppies, look for an AAFCO statement that specifically includes the growth of large-size dogs expected to weigh 70 pounds or more as adults, rather than one that excludes them.
How Much Do Whole-Food Pet Foods Cost?
One of the biggest differences between the brands featured in this article is price. And when you're feeding multiple large dogs like I am, those differences can add up quickly!
But comparing pet food prices isn't quite as simple as looking at the cost per pound. Frozen raw and gently cooked foods contain significantly more moisture than kibble or air-dried foods, so you'll generally need to feed more by weight to get the same amount of calories. Some foods are also considerably more calorie-dense than others.
To make this comparison as fair as possible, I've based every calculation on a 75 lb adult dog consuming 1,400 calories per day. I used the calorie content of each recipe to calculate the daily feeding amount, along with the estimated daily and monthly costs.
One important thing to note is that these feeding amounts may differ from the recommendations on each brand's website. Rather than using each manufacturer's feeding guidelines, I've calculated how much of each food would be needed to provide the same 1,400 calories per day. Actual calorie requirements vary depending on a dog's age, activity level, metabolism, and body condition, so these numbers are intended for comparison rather than as specific feeding recommendations.
For consistency, I've used beef recipes wherever possible, along with the largest practical package sizes available to get the best pricing. For brands without a complete and balanced beef recipe, I've selected another protein. I've also based the comparison on the specific recipes and feeding formats I personally reviewed, rather than necessarily choosing the least expensive option each brand offers. Some brands offer multiple formats, such as frozen and freeze-dried raw, and the price difference between them can be pretty significant!
Whole-Food Pet Food Price Comparison
Prices checked November 2026. Monthly costs are based on a 75 lb adult dog consuming approximately 1,400 calories daily for 30 days, with feeding amounts rounded to the nearest ¼ cup or ¼ pound. Prices reflect the largest practical package sizes and available recurring discounts where noted. Shipping is included where applicable, while taxes are excluded. Actual feeding requirements and prices may vary.
What's interesting is just how much prices vary, even between foods prepared using similar methods. Nature's Logic is one of the most affordable options in this comparison, while Carna4 is considerably more expensive than traditional kibble but still costs substantially less than most of the fresh and raw foods.
Buying in bulk can also make a significant difference. Brands like BJ's Raw, Answers, Bones & Co., and Allprovide offer larger purchasing options that can considerably reduce the cost per meal compared with buying smaller packages. Of course, those savings depend on having enough freezer space and being able to use the food within the recommended freezer storage period!
Keep in mind that these are estimated costs based on retail prices at the time of comparison. Some prices reflect bulk purchasing or subscription discounts, and shipping is included where applicable. Taxes aren't included. Prices and availability can vary, so your actual feeding costs may be different.
Ultimately, I don't think the most expensive food is automatically the best. What matters is finding a nutritionally complete diet that works well for your pet and is something you can comfortably afford to feed long-term.
Final Thoughts
After spending years feeding different brands and researching what actually goes into pet food, I'm really glad to see more companies offering complete and balanced diets made primarily with whole-food ingredients. What I especially love is that these options aren't limited to raw feeding anymore. Whether you prefer kibble, gently cooked, or raw, there are some great options available! If you're considering frozen raw food specifically, you can also check out my Best Frozen Raw Dog Food Brands comparison.
One thing I've learned from feeding so many different foods is that every dog has their own preferences, and what works wonderfully for one might not be the best fit for another. I don't believe there's one perfect diet for every dog or cat. What matters most to me is finding food that's nutritionally complete for their needs, made with quality ingredients, and something they genuinely do well on. Hopefully, sharing my experiences with these brands helps you find something that works for your own pets, too!